Personal tools
 
Views

Argument: Large polygamous families generally enjoy lower quality of life

From Debatepedia

Jump to: navigation, search

Reasons to agree

  1. Saye R. Gbetu. "A Case Against Legalizing Polygamy". The Perspective. September 13, 2001 - "With all things being equal, the quality of life for a family decreases as the family size increases."
  2. Andrea Sachs. "Polygamy Survivor Carolyn Jessop". Time. Oct. 24, 2007 - "Those families were so enormous. Your husband had 50 children. How did anybody pay the bills?
  3. [Carolyn Jessop:] Life is not the same as normal society. There's not enough money to go around. So somebody is going to have to go without the basic necessities they need. The other thing is, we worked really hard. There might be one woman who would try to maintain life in the home, and then everybody else had to work. I worked as a teacher and I gave Merril all my money. It was just a mandatory requirement. You'd turn everything in. He pays the bills and then he gives you back what he feels you deserve or need. If he chooses to give you nothing back, then you just have to deal with that. He also had the power to decide whether he wanted to eat out at fancy restaurants and eat steaks, and we went without groceries. As a man, that was his choice."

Reasons to disagree

  1. Not all polygamous families have more kids than they can support. Having more children than you can support is the problem. Often polygamous have more families, and it is sort of a causal relationship, but it is not by necessity a direct causal relationship. This argument can not be used against polygamous families that have lots of money or use birth control. Besides, you can't just measure quality of life with money.

Interest, values, and assumptions of those who agree

Interest & Values of those who disagree

Parent debate

Score

  • Reasons to agree: +1
  • Reasons to disagree: -0
  • Reasons to agree with reasons to agree: +0
  • Reasons to disagree with reason to agree: -0
  • Reasons to agree with reasons to disagree: -0
  • Reasons to disagree with reasons to disagree: +0
  • Total: +1

Problem with the site? 

Tweet a bug on bugtwits
.