Argument: The ends (deterrence) should not justify means (capital punishment)
- Debate: Death penalty, con, "public safety" subquestion.
Extended argument and supporting evidence
- Hugo Adam Bedau, "The Case Against the Death Penalty", (1992) - "Executions give society the unmistakable message that human life no longer deserves respect when it is useful to take it and that homicide is legitimate when deemed justified by pragmatic concerns. A decent and humane society does not deliberately kill human beings. An execution is a dramatic, public spectacle of official, violent homicide that teaches the permissibility of killing people to solve social problems -- the worst possible example to set for society. In this century, governments have too often attempted to justify their lethal fury by the benefits such killing would bring to the rest of society. The bloodshed is real and deeply destructive of the common decency of the community; the benefits are illusory."